Top Shelf Stud (Chicago Players 3) by Kate Meader-review

Amazon.com / Amazon.ca / B&N / KOBO / Google Play / Indigo /
ABOUT THE BOOK: Release Date February 24, 2026
The snail doc wants a baby. I volunteered to do the deed. But it isn’t long before I realize a “donation” will never be enough. I want to be a dad, but most of all, I want her.
Franky
When confronted with the cold, hard facts of her diminishing chances to be a mom, what’s a woman of science to do?
Make a spreadsheet of eligible donors, of course.
Finding a man for life is not in the cards, but one for this singular purpose? I can do that. As the daughter of a Chicago Rebels legend and an expert in the field of gastropods—more commonly known as snails and slugs—I have plenty of choices in the worlds of both hockey and academia. The selection process should be easy, especially as my methodology has already eliminated several options, including Jason Isner, childhood nemesis and recently acquired defenseman for the Rebels. I’ve always considered him arrogant, cruel, and to be honest, not the brightest bulb.
I’m rarely wrong. But I might have been mistaken about Jason . . .
Jason
I surprised even myself when I offered to be Franky St. James’s baby daddy, but fatherhood has been a dream of mine forever. If I can achieve my goal without the hassle of a relationship, even better. I won’t be one of those “pump and dump” donors, though. I want the whole package: nighttime feedings, shopping for cute onesies, teaching my kid to skate. I’m in it for life, and as Franky and I travel this road together, I start to imagine what that life might look like. Not just a baby, but a family of my own.
The thing is, the doc has all sorts of hypotheses about jocks and relationships, and it’s going to take a lot of persuasion—sexy and otherwise—to prove her wrong. She might think the mating rituals of her beloved snails are the only “coupling” worth studying, but I’m determined to show her that when it comes to seeking a mate, this player is as driven as any species in the animal kingdom.
Because making a baby is just the beginning . .
••••••
REVIEW:TOP SHELF STUD is the third instalment in Kate Meader’s contemporary, adult CHICAGO PLAYERS erotic, second generation, hockey romance series, set in the author’s Chicago Rebels and Rookie Rebels series. This is thirty-six year old, professional hockey player Jason Isner, and PhD professor Dr Franky St. James’s story line. TOP SHELF STUD can be read as a stand alone without any difficulty. Any important information from the previous story lines is revealed where necessary . Franky is the daughter of Bren St. James (Hooked On You), and Jason is the half-brother to Theo Kershaw (Instacrush)
Told from dual first person perspectives (Jason and Franky) TOP SHELF STUD follows Dr. Franky Isner as she considers her options for a baby daddy. At thirty-eight eight years old, Franky is desperate to start a family but with no significant other on the horizon, Franky considers the friends in her life. .When her childhood nemesis gets wind of Franky’s plans, Jason Isner offers up his services as baby daddy but Franky has no plans to marry or begin a relationship, and let’s Jason know, she is willing to raise the child alone. throughout the ensuing months, Jason begins to fall for the woman who carries his child but Franky struggles with past heartache, heartache she blames on our story line hero, and considers Jason nothing more than the sperm donor.
The world building focuses on misunderstanding and miscommunication between our story line couples, as well as Franky’s passive aggressive behavior as it pertains to the man with whom she will fall in love. Franky is determined to raise the child without Jason’s help but Jason wants to be part of their child’s life.
The relationship between Franky and Jason begins acrimoniously . Childhood nemesis but for reasons Jason cannot fathom-Franky’s memory is long, and one perceived and painful betrayal finds Franky struggling to forgive or forget. The $ex scenes are intimate and passionate without the use of over the top, sexually graphic language and text.
There is a large ensemble cast of colorful, familiar and energetic secondary and supporting characters including characters from the author’s Chicago Rebels and Rookie Rebels series.
TOP SHELF STUD is a story of family and relationships, acceptance , friendships and love. The character driven premise is captivating, entertaining and emotional; the romance is seductive but struggles with preconceived notions, independence, and self-reliance; the characters are determined and charismatic.
Copy supplied for review
Reviewed by Sandy


Kate Meader
Website | Facebook | Twitter | Reader’s Group | Bookbub | Goodreads | Newsletter | Amazon Author Profile
Originally from Ireland, USA Today bestselling author Kate Meader cut her romance reader teeth on Maeve Binchy and Jilly Cooper novels, with some Harlequins thrown in for variety. Give her tales about brooding mill owners, oversexed equestrians, and men who can rock an apron or a fire hose, and she’s there. Now based in Chicago, she writes sexy contemporary romance with alpha heroes and strong heroines who can match their men quip for quip.















