Her Sweetest Mistake (One-Night Scandals 1) by Katherine Garbera-review

Amazon.com / Amazon.ca / Amazon.uk / Amazon.au /
Don’t own a Kindle? Download the FREE Amazon Kindle App for your mobile device or pc
ABOUT THE BOOK: Release Date February 19, 2026
A second-chance romance with an ex-husband, a small-town bakery, and the Marine who never stopped loving her.
Cupcake baker Alysse Dresden likes her life sweet, simple, and drama-free. But one surprise delivery brings her face-to-face with the man she swore she’d never fall for again—her ex-husband, former Marine Jay Michener.
Their weeklong marriage ended years ago, but the chemistry? Still explosive.
Jay’s back in town with one last shot to fix everything before he reenlists. Alysse knows letting him in again could shatter her carefully rebuilt heart. Jay believes they were always meant to be—if he can prove he’s no longer the man who walked away.
Old wounds. Undeniable heat. One last chance at the love they never got right.
Alysse must decide whether trusting Jay again is the sweetest risk she’ll ever take…or her biggest mistake all over again.
••••••
REVIEW:HER SWEETEST MISTAKE is the first instalment in Katherine Garbera’s contemporary, adult ONE NIGHT SCANDALS erotica romance series. This is Marine sniper Jay Michener, and baker Alysse Dresden’s story line.
Told from dual omniscient third person perspectives (Jay and Alysse) HER SWEETEST MISTAKE focuses on the second chance relationship between our story line couple. Approximately four years earlier, a trip to Las Vegas found Alysse Dresden married to US Marine Jay Michener, a man she had only met days before. Ten days together ended when Jay ghosted our story line heroine, resulting in Alysse filing for divorce. Fast forward to present day, Jay Michener has returned stateside to reconsider his future, whether to re-enlist or properly seduce the woman whose heart he destroyed.
The world building follows the rekindling romance and relationship between our story line couple but Jay is struggling with issues of low self esteem, while Alysse is battling between head and heart, unable to trust the man who broke her heart. Alysse has established herself as a small business owner, why Jay continues to waffle on his plans for the future. The $ex scenes are erotic, and provocative, without the use of over the top, sexually graphic language and text but I did not feel any palpable sexual attraction.
We are introduced to Alysse’s co-worker Staci; and Jay’s fellow Marine turned security expert Lucien.
HER SWEETEST MISTAKE is story of struggle and heart break, forgiveness and love.The premise is entertaining but was dry and often blase. Jay’s inability to make a decision (waffling back and forth about his future) was matched by both Jay and Alysse’s constant miscommunication. The characters were flawed yet determined; the romance was spirited but felt like they were going through the motions. As this is my first KG read, I am not sure if this is the norm or I expected something more.
Copy supplied for review
Reviewed by Sandy

